Italian Market

Created in 1958 by John Bonfatto, we have kept the Bonanza unchanged since. We still use the same bread & meats and slice everything to the exact measurements that John created.

Our Services

We have DOP, imported and specialty deli & groceries available in our market. We are always finding new products to bring in, so stop in to see what's new!

One of the most important aspects to our business is the quality of ingredients. We make everything we can in-house and only get in products that we truly love.

Quality Ingredients

401 West High Street  |  Bellefonte  |  PA  16823

 (814) 353-3330

 Located in the Historic District of Downtown Bellefonte, PA. Bonfatto's is a third generation 100 year old family business. Guy and Pauline Bonfatto started it all on August 15, 1919 in downtown Bellefonte as a grocery and home delivery business. In 1958 John Bonfatto invented our famous Bonanza Sub Sandwich, which today is still a mainstay of the business. n 1990, grandson David Letterman (son of Rose Bonfatto) joined the business. David had always envisioned a smaller Italian Market. David and wife Sherri renovated a historical building and moved their business back downtown Bellefonte as Bonfatto's Italian Market and Corner Cafe.

Bonanza Sub

We extract espresso using a traditional lever-pull machine resulting in the best tasting coffee possible. We offer traditional coffee drinks along with a few modern twists.

Specialty coffee


Family owned since 1919

M-F: 7am-7pm

Sat: 8am-7pm

Sun: 9am-2pm